TutorChase logo
Login
OCR A-Level Physics Notes

18.1.5 Massive star outcomes and remnants

OCR Specification focus:
‘Massive stars become red supergiants then undergo supernova, leaving neutron stars or black holes.’

Massive stars undergo dramatic evolutionary pathways that differ significantly from Sun-like stars, progressing through extreme internal transformations, explosive endings, and the creation of dense stellar remnants that shape the structure and chemical composition of the universe. Their behaviour is governed by mass-dependent nuclear processes, rapid core evolution, and catastrophic gravitational collapse that produces some of the most energetic phenomena known in astrophysics.

Evolution of Massive Stars

Massive stars, typically with initial masses greater than about eight solar masses, follow a sequence of stages that reflects increasing central temperature and pressure. Their structure changes more rapidly and violently than that of low-mass stars, owing to the faster consumption of nuclear fuel and the enormous gravitational forces acting on their cores.

Red Supergiant Stage

As hydrogen in the core becomes depleted, the star can no longer sustain core hydrogen fusion, forcing structural readjustment. The outer layers expand and cool, forming a red supergiant, an extremely large and luminous star with a swollen outer envelope. During this phase, nuclear fusion continues in shells surrounding an increasingly compressed core.

Red supergiant: A very large, cool, highly luminous evolved star formed when a massive star’s outer layers expand during post-main-sequence evolution.

Red supergiants often display complex internal layering, with different fusion reactions occurring simultaneously at varying depths.

Onion-shell structure in an evolved massive star, with concentric layers where different nuclei fuse. The innermost iron core is inert to further exothermic fusion, setting up imminent collapse. Labels highlight successive burning shells consistent with massive-star evolution. Source.

This multi-shell burning allows the synthesis of progressively heavier elements up to iron.

The star’s enhanced luminosity and extended radius result in significant mass loss. Stellar winds strip the outer atmosphere, expelling heavy elements into the surrounding interstellar medium, a process crucial for cosmic chemical enrichment.

End of Fusion and Core Instability

Fusion in the core proceeds through elements such as helium, carbon, neon, oxygen, and silicon. Each stage produces an inert core of the next heavier element. The ultimate result is the formation of an iron core, which cannot undergo exothermic fusion. Without an energy source to counteract gravity, the core becomes unstable.

Iron core: The innermost region of a massive star composed primarily of iron nuclei, incapable of releasing energy through further fusion reactions.

Between the exhaustion of silicon fuel and the onset of collapse, only a brief period elapses. The core becomes supported solely by electron degeneracy pressure, which is eventually overwhelmed by gravity as the mass of the core approaches a critical limit.

Core-Collapse Supernova

The fundamental fate of a massive star is determined by the catastrophic collapse of its core followed by an outward explosion known as a Type II supernova. This event marks the destruction of the star’s outer layers and the birth of a compact remnant.

Stages of a core-collapse supernova: collapse of the iron core, formation and temporary stalling of the shock, and neutrino heating that revives the shock to expel the envelope. The final panel shows ejected material and a compact remnant. Labels (a–f) provide a clear, stepwise physical narrative. Source.

Collapse Phase

The collapse begins when electron degeneracy pressure fails. The star’s core contracts rapidly, and protons and electrons combine to form neutrons and neutrinos in a process known as electron capture. The density rises dramatically, creating a proto-neutron core. Neutrinos escape initially but soon become trapped as density increases.

Rebound and Explosion

When nuclear densities are reached, the collapse halts abruptly as the extremely compressed matter becomes incompressible. This sudden stop generates a shockwave propagating outwards. Although initially stalled, the shock is re-energised partly by neutrinos streaming from the core, enabling it to blast apart the star’s outer layers.

Bullet points highlighting key features of a supernova explosion:

  • Rapid core collapse to near-nuclear density

  • Shockwave formation and revival

  • Ejection of outer layers at high velocity

  • Intense neutrino emission transporting energy

  • Production of heavy elements beyond iron

The supernova disperses newly formed heavy elements into space, seeding future star systems with essential materials.

Formation of Stellar Remnants

Neutron Stars

If the mass of the collapsed core is below a critical threshold, the result is a neutron star, an extraordinarily dense body composed almost entirely of neutrons. Typical neutron stars have masses around 1.4–2 solar masses and radii of only about 10 km.

Neutron star: A dense stellar remnant formed when a core-collapse supernova compresses matter into a state composed almost entirely of neutrons.

Neutron stars may rotate rapidly and possess strong magnetic fields, giving rise to observable phenomena such as pulsars.

Diagram of a pulsar: a rotating neutron star whose magnetic axis and spin axis are misaligned, producing sweeping radiation beams. Field lines and beam geometry are clearly indicated. This includes some extra context about lighthouse-like pulsations, which is helpful but not required by the syllabus. Source.

Black Holes

If the core remnant exceeds the maximum supportable mass of a neutron star, gravitational collapse continues, leading to the formation of a black hole. No known physical pressure can halt this collapse.

Black hole: A region of spacetime containing matter compressed to such an extent that nothing, not even light, can escape its gravitational field.

Massive stars that produce black holes typically have particularly large initial masses or undergo significant fallback of material onto the remnant after the supernova.

Overview of Mass-Dependent Outcomes

  • Moderately massive stars → red supergiant → supernova → neutron star

  • Very massive stars → red supergiant → supernova → black hole

The pathway of a massive star is therefore determined chiefly by its initial mass and the behaviour of its collapsing core.

FAQ

Fallback occurs when some of the ejected layers do not reach escape velocity during the explosion.
It is more likely if the shockwave is weaker or if the star had a particularly massive envelope.

• Stronger gravity in very massive stars increases fallback.
• More fallback can push a neutron star over its stability limit, forming a black hole.

During collapse, enormous numbers of neutrinos are produced through electron capture and thermal processes.
Although neutrinos interact weakly with matter, the stellar core becomes dense enough to temporarily trap them.

A large fraction of the gravitational potential energy released in the collapse emerges as neutrinos, making them the primary carriers of energy—far exceeding the energy emitted as visible light.

Iron has the highest binding energy per nucleon of common elements.
Fusion reactions that create elements heavier than iron absorb energy instead of releasing it.

This means the core can no longer generate outward thermal pressure from fusion, making gravitational collapse inevitable.

Rapidly rotating massive stars can leave behind neutron stars with extremely high spin rates.
Angular momentum is conserved during collapse, so the core’s rotation increases dramatically.

Rotation can also:
• Strengthen magnetic fields through dynamo processes
• Influence the geometry of the supernova explosion
• Affect whether a jet-driven explosion occurs in the most extreme events

A neutron star may be detected as a pulsar if its radiation beams sweep across Earth.
Its strong X-ray or radio emission can also reveal its presence.

A black hole leaves no direct signal, but astronomers infer it through:
• The absence of a detectable compact remnant
• Motion of nearby gas
• X-ray emission from material accreting onto the unseen remnant

Practice Questions

Question 1 (2 marks)
State what stellar remnant is formed from
(a) a core-collapse supernova in a star of moderately high initial mass, and
(b) a core-collapse supernova in a star of very large initial mass.


Mark Scheme:

(a) Neutron star formed from a star of moderately high initial mass. (1 mark)

(b) Black hole formed from a star of very large initial mass. (1 mark)

Question 2 (5 marks)
Describe the sequence of events occurring in a massive star that lead from the red supergiant stage to the formation of a neutron star or a black hole. In your answer, refer to the role of the iron core, electron degeneracy pressure, and the supernova mechanism.

Mark Scheme:

Award up to 5 marks for the following points:

• In the red supergiant stage, multiple fusion shells create heavier elements up to iron in the core. (1 mark)

• Iron core cannot undergo further exothermic fusion, leading to instability. (1 mark)

• Electron degeneracy pressure is insufficient to support the core once it exceeds a critical mass, triggering rapid collapse. (1 mark)

• Core collapse produces a shockwave; neutrinos help re-energise this shock to expel outer layers in a supernova. (1 mark)

• Remaining core becomes a neutron star if below the maximum neutron-star mass, or collapses further to form a black hole if above it. (1 mark)

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
Your details
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email