AP Syllabus focus:
‘Students express inner and outer radii as differences between functions and the axis of revolution, then integrate π[(outer)² − (inner)²] with respect to x or y.’
Washer integrals for horizontal or vertical lines allow volumes of solids of revolution to be computed by measuring changing radii relative to shifted axes using definite integrals.
Washer Integrals for Horizontal or Vertical Lines
A washer-based volume arises when a region is revolved around a horizontal or vertical line, producing a solid with a hollow center. This hollow center creates a ring-shaped cross section whose area must be computed by comparing an outer radius to an inner radius. Because these radii depend on the distance from the region’s bounding curves to the chosen line of revolution, setting up the correct expressions is essential for accurate volume calculations. In this subsubtopic, the AP Calculus AB focus is on expressing these radii as differences between functions and the axis of revolution, then writing the corresponding integral using the washer formula.
Understanding Horizontal and Vertical Lines of Revolution
When revolving a region around a horizontal line such as , the radii measure vertical distances between the curve(s) and the axis. When revolving around a vertical line such as , the radii measure horizontal distances. The orientation determines whether the integral must be written with respect to or , based on how the radius naturally varies across the region.
Key Idea: Measuring Distance to the Axis
The radius of revolution is always defined as a nonnegative distance from a curve to the axis being used. Distances depend on whether the curve lies above or below a horizontal axis or to the right or left of a vertical axis.
Radius of Revolution: The nonnegative distance from a bounding curve of the region to the line around which the region is revolved.
A sentence between blocks is needed, so here it is to maintain proper spacing and explanation before introducing the equation.
= distance from farther curve to the axis of revolution
= distance from nearer curve to the axis of revolution
The integral sums the volumes of these infinitesimally thin washers to give the total volume of the solid of revolution.

A planar region is sliced by a thin rectangle perpendicular to a horizontal axis of revolution. When the slice is revolved, it generates a washer-shaped cross-section whose outer and inner edges track the bounding curves. This image emphasizes how a continuous family of such washers accumulates to form the full solid. Source.
Determining Whether to Integrate with Respect to x or y
Choosing the correct variable prevents unnecessary complications and ensures the washer method is applied efficiently. The selection depends on the orientation of the axis:
Revolving around a horizontal line ()
Radii are vertical distances.
Use integration with respect to , provided the curves are functions of .
Revolving around a vertical line ()
Radii are horizontal distances.
Use integration with respect to , provided the curves are functions of .
If the region has boundaries more naturally expressed in the opposite orientation, re-expressing the curves may simplify the radii expressions.
Constructing the Outer and Inner Radii
The washer method always requires identifying two distances:
Outer radius: distance from the most distant bounding curve to the axis
Inner radius: distance from the closest bounding curve to the axis
These distances must always remain nonnegative and must correctly reflect which curve is farther or nearer across the entire interval.
When the Axis Is Horizontal ()
To compute radii:
Outer radius:
If the upper curve is , then
distance = .
Inner radius:
If the lower curve is |g(x) - k|y=ky=kx = cx = f(y)|f(y) - c|x = g(y)|g(y) - c|yxxy\pi[(\text{outer radius})^{2} - (\text{inner radius})^{2}]$ with appropriate limits.
Ensure radii remain nonnegative over the entire interval.
Visual Reasoning with Axes of Revolution
Conceptualizing the geometry strengthens understanding. A horizontal line of revolution produces washers stacked left to right, while a vertical line of revolution produces washers stacked bottom to top. Because the shape of each washer depends on distance to the axis, graph inspection and boundary verification prevent sign errors in radius expressions.
FAQ
The correct choice depends on which boundary lies farther from the axis of revolution at each point in the domain. A constant boundary such as a horizontal or vertical line can act as either the inner or outer boundary, depending on its position relative to the curve.
Check the geometry across the entire interval. If the curve crosses or approaches the axis at any point, the role of the radii may switch, requiring a split into sub-intervals.
A shifted axis creates a hollow space, because the region no longer touches the axis of revolution. This gap produces an inner radius greater than zero, which prevents the region from forming a solid disc.
The washer method accounts for this gap by subtracting the volume removed by the inner radius from the volume generated by the outer radius.
Students often incorrectly subtract in the wrong order, producing negative radii. Distances must always be non-negative.
Another frequent mistake is mixing up whether distances should be taken vertically or horizontally. Always use vertical distances for horizontal axes and horizontal distances for vertical axes.
Sketching the region and axis before writing expressions reduces these errors significantly.
If the washer radii vary in the direction perpendicular to the slices, switching the variable often creates simpler expressions.
For example:
• A vertical line of revolution usually favours integration with respect to y.
• A horizontal line of revolution usually favours integration with respect to x.
If the functions are difficult to rearrange into the needed form, sticking with the original variable may be more efficient.
Confirm that the same curve remains consistently farther from the axis than the other boundary across the interval. If this relationship changes, the region no longer forms a simple washer on that interval.
Check for:
• Intersection points between curves
• Points where a curve approaches or crosses the axis of revolution
• Regions where the inner radius might become zero or negative
These features indicate the need to split the integral for accuracy.
Practice Questions
Question 1 (1–3 marks)
A region in the xy-plane is bounded above by the line y = 5, below by the curve y = x, and between x = 0 and x = 4. The region is revolved about the horizontal line y = 1.
(a) State an expression for the outer radius in terms of x.
(b) State an expression for the inner radius in terms of x.
(c) Write, but do not evaluate, a definite integral representing the volume of the resulting solid using the washer method.
Question 1
(a)
• Outer radius correctly stated as distance from y = 5 to y = 1, giving radius = 5 − 1 = 4, or written as a constant 4.
(1 mark)
(b)
• Inner radius correctly stated as distance from y = x to y = 1, giving radius = x − 1 or 1 − x depending on candidate’s convention, but must be non-negative for the interval.
(1 mark)
(c)
• Correct washer integral written: integral from x = 0 to x = 4 of pi[(outer radius) squared − (inner radius) squared] dx.
(1 mark)
Total: 3 marks
Question 2 (4–6 marks)
The region bounded by the curves x = y + 2 and x = 6, for 0 ≤ y ≤ 3, is revolved about the vertical line x = 0 to form a solid.
(a) Determine the outer radius as a function of y.
(b) Determine the inner radius as a function of y.
(c) Write a definite integral in terms of y that represents the volume of the solid.
(d) Explain briefly why integration with respect to y is the appropriate choice in this problem.
Question 2
(a)
• Outer radius correctly stated as distance from x = 6 to x = 0, giving radius = 6.
(1 mark)
(b)
• Inner radius correctly stated as distance from x = y + 2 to x = 0, giving radius = y + 2.
(1 mark)
(c)
• Correct washer integral written: integral from y = 0 to y = 3 of pi[(outer radius) squared − (inner radius) squared] dy.
(2 marks: 1 for structure, 1 for correct substitution of radii)
(d)
• Explanation identifies that radii vary horizontally and depend on y, so horizontal slices produce washers aligned with the axis of revolution.
(1–2 marks depending on clarity)
Total: 5–6 marks
