TutorChase logo
Login
AP Human Geography Notes

7.3.5 Energy Use as a Development Measure: Fossil Fuels vs. Renewables

AP Syllabus focus:
‘Energy use patterns—reliance on fossil fuels versus renewable energy—can indicate development levels and environmental trade-offs.’

Energy consumption patterns reveal a country’s technological capacity, environmental impact, and stage of development, highlighting differences between fossil-fuel dependence and renewable-energy adoption.

Energy Use as a Development Indicator

Energy use reflects the level of industrialization, technological sophistication, and overall economic development within a country. Higher levels of energy consumption typically correlate with more complex economies, larger manufacturing sectors, higher household incomes, and increased access to infrastructure such as electricity and transportation. Because energy is required for agriculture, industry, and services, examining the type and quantity of energy used helps geographers compare living conditions and economic structure across places.

Pasted image

This chart shows global primary energy consumption by source from 2000 to 2021, highlighting the continued dominance of fossil fuels alongside the rapid growth of renewable energy. The relative thickness of each band indicates how much each source contributes to total world energy use. The recent increase in solar and wind underscores how technological change and policy can shift development toward cleaner energy, even while overall demand keeps rising. Source.

Fossil Fuels and Development Patterns

Many developed countries historically relied on fossil fuels—coal, oil, and natural gas—to power factories, transportation networks, and electricity generation. These fuels were abundant, energy-dense, and relatively cheap to extract during the 19th and 20th centuries. As a result, countries in the global core integrated fossil fuels into nearly every part of their economic systems.
However, fossil-fuel dependence also created significant environmental trade-offs, including air pollution, greenhouse-gas emissions, and ecological degradation from extraction.

Pasted image

This diagram shows the basic fossil fuel life cycle, moving from underground resources through discovery and extraction to combustion. The final step emphasizes pollution, highlighting how using fossil fuels for industrial growth and electricity generation produces environmental costs. Although simplified, the diagram captures the key stages that connect fossil-fuel-based development to air pollution and climate impacts. Source.

  • Advantages of fossil fuels in development:

    • High energy density supports industrial manufacturing.

    • Consistent and easily transportable energy supply.

    • Existing infrastructure such as pipelines, refineries, and power plants.

  • Disadvantages and trade-offs:

    • Large contribution to carbon emissions.

    • Long-term price volatility driven by global markets.

    • Environmental harm from mining, drilling, and combustion.

Because of these factors, fossil-fuel consumption patterns often demonstrate the historical trajectory of development rather than a sustainable long-term pathway.

Renewables and Transitioning Economies

Renewable energy refers to naturally replenished sources such as solar, wind, hydropower, geothermal, and biomass. These sources have grown in importance as countries seek cleaner, more sustainable energy strategies.

Renewable Energy: Energy derived from naturally replenishing resources that do not deplete when used.

Many developed countries are now shifting away from fossil fuels toward renewables due to concerns about climate change, environmental health, and long-term energy security. This transition often requires high levels of investment, specialized technology, and supportive policy environments.

Countries in the semiperiphery and periphery may adopt renewables for different reasons. Some seek energy independence because they cannot afford imported fossil fuels, while others possess strong natural advantages such as high solar irradiation or steady wind patterns. Still, many face structural challenges, including limited capital, grid instability, and weaker regulatory frameworks.

  • Factors encouraging renewable adoption:

    • Government incentives and global climate agreements.

    • Falling costs of solar and wind technologies.

    • Improved energy storage and grid-management systems.

  • Challenges for developing regions:

    • High upfront installation costs.

    • Lack of financing tools and technical expertise.

    • Difficulty integrating variable energy sources into existing grids.

These differences create spatial patterns in renewable-energy use that reflect broader disparities in access to technology, investment, and governance.

Fossil Fuels vs. Renewables as Comparative Measures of Development

The balance between fossil fuels and renewables provides insight into a country’s economic priorities, environmental practices, and capacity for technological innovation. High-income countries typically use far more total energy, but they also increasingly invest in renewables as part of a shift toward sustainable development. Middle-income countries often show mixed patterns, using fossil fuels for industrial growth while gradually incorporating renewables. Lower-income countries may use less total energy overall but rely on traditional biomass or imported fuels, making transitions more complex.

Energy Intensity and Environmental Trade-Offs

Energy intensity—the amount of energy used to produce one unit of economic output—helps indicate how efficiently a country uses energy. Although energy intensity is not the primary focus of this subsubtopic, it relates to the broader idea that countries with advanced technologies can often produce more output with less energy. Fossil-fuel-heavy economies often experience higher environmental costs per unit of development, demonstrating a key trade-off: economic growth historically depended on fossil fuels, but long-term sustainability requires a shift toward renewables.

Sentence between blocks.

Energy Intensity(EI)=Total Energy UseGDP Energy\ Intensity (EI) = \frac{Total\ Energy\ Use}{GDP}
Total Energy Use Total\ Energy\ Use = Total national energy consumed (joules or BTUs)
GDP GDP = Gross Domestic Product (dollars)

Energy intensity helps illustrate how economies with advanced renewable technologies can improve efficiency and reduce environmental costs over time.

Spatial Patterns in Energy Use and Development

Clear spatial distinctions exist between core, semiperiphery, and periphery regions regarding energy consumption and source types.

Core Countries

  • Historically heavy fossil-fuel users due to industrialization.

  • Increasing renewable investment driven by environmental policy.

  • Build advanced grids capable of incorporating variable energy flows.

  • Focus on reducing carbon emissions and modernizing infrastructure.

Semiperiphery Countries

  • Rapid industrial growth often relies on fossil fuels for affordability.

  • Growing renewable sectors, especially solar and wind.

  • Transitional economies balancing development needs with sustainability goals.

  • Common sites for international investment in renewable projects.

Periphery Countries

  • Lower overall energy consumption but high dependence on imported fossil fuels or traditional biomass.

  • Renewable adoption influenced by cost, geography, and aid programs.

  • Infrastructure gaps and funding shortages slow expansion of modern energy systems.

These spatial differences help geographers assess how development strategies vary and how shifts toward renewables relate to both economic capacity and environmental pressures.

FAQ

Governments shape energy use through subsidies, taxes, and regulatory frameworks. Subsidies for fossil fuels make them cheaper, reinforcing dependence, while renewable subsidies support technology adoption.

Policies such as carbon pricing, emissions standards, and renewable portfolio requirements also shift investment patterns. Long-term strategies often determine whether a country diversifies its energy mix or remains reliant on traditional fuels.

Some developing countries have strong natural advantages such as high solar exposure, steady winds, or major hydropower resources, making renewables cost-effective even with limited budgets.

In addition, international aid, climate finance, and development loans help fund renewable projects. These countries may also lack entrenched fossil fuel industries, allowing for quicker transitions when new technologies become affordable.

Energy storage systems help stabilise electricity supply by storing excess power generated from sources like wind and solar and releasing it during periods of low production.

Storage reduces reliance on backup fossil-fuel power plants and increases grid reliability. As technology improves, storage makes renewable-dominant energy systems more feasible, especially in regions with variable weather.

Urban areas tend to consume more energy because they concentrate industry, services, and transport networks. Fossil fuels often dominate during early urban growth phases due to affordability and existing infrastructure.

As cities develop, investments in public transport, efficient buildings, and renewable-powered grids help shift energy use patterns. Wealthier cities often lead in adopting clean technologies, while rapidly growing cities may struggle with infrastructure demands.

Countries within a region differ in governance quality, financial resources, and access to technology. These differences affect their ability to build and maintain renewable infrastructure.

Geography also matters: some places have abundant hydropower potential, while others have limited solar or wind availability. Regional political cooperation or conflict can further influence cross-border energy investment and grid integration.

Practice Questions

(1–3 marks)
Explain one way in which a country’s reliance on renewable energy can indicate its level of development.

Question 1 (1–3 marks)

  • 1 mark: Identifies a basic link between renewable energy use and development (e.g., higher development often enables greater investment in renewables).

  • 2 marks: Provides a clear explanation of why renewable adoption is associated with development (e.g., requires advanced technology, strong governance, or financial capacity).

  • 3 marks: Offers a developed explanation with an additional detail (e.g., renewable infrastructure demonstrates long-term planning, environmental regulation, or energy security priorities).

(4–6 marks)
Using examples, analyse how differences in fossil fuel use and renewable energy adoption reflect broader patterns of economic development among core, semi-periphery, and periphery regions.

Question 2 (4–6 marks)

  • 1–2 marks: Describes general differences in energy use between countries or regions.

  • 3–4 marks: Explains how fossil fuel dependence or renewable adoption reflects economic development levels in core, semi-periphery, and periphery regions.

  • 5–6 marks: Uses specific examples (countries or regions) and provides clear analytical links between energy patterns and development (e.g., core countries transitioning due to policy and technology; semi-periphery balancing industrial growth with renewable investment; periphery facing structural barriers).

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
Your details
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email