AP Syllabus focus:
‘Information from first and second implicit derivatives is used to study slopes, critical points, and concavity of implicit curves, just as with explicitly defined functions.’
A curve defined implicitly can display rich behavior, and its first and second derivatives allow us to understand changes in slope, the presence of critical points, and the bending of the graph. These ideas parallel explicit differentiation but require additional attention because derivatives often depend on both x and y.
Interpreting Behavior from Implicit Derivatives
Understanding the Role of Derivatives in Implicit Relations
Implicit relations link x and y through an equation rather than a solved-out function, so their derivatives describe how the curve behaves locally. The first derivative indicates slope, while the second derivative reveals concavity and changes in how steepness develops. Even though the relation may not be written as , analyzing it mirrors the interpretation used for explicit functions.
Implicit relation: An equation involving x and y in which y is not isolated as a function of x, but the curve’s behavior can still be analyzed using derivatives.
Between derivatives and geometry lies a direct connection: slopes communicate direction, and concavity communicates curvature. These interpretations help determine whether the graph is rising, falling, bending upward, or bending downward at any given point on the curve.
Interpreting the First Implicit Derivative
The first derivative gives a point-by-point description of slope.

This diagram illustrates how a tangent line represents the instantaneous slope of a curve at a point. The tangent touches the graph once and shares its slope there. This same geometric interpretation holds for implicitly defined curves even when is not expressed explicitly as a function of . Source.
Key uses of the first implicit derivative include:
Determining where the curve has positive slope, meaning it rises as x increases.
Identifying where the curve has negative slope, showing it falls as x increases.
Locating horizontal tangents, when , which indicate momentary changes in direction.
Identifying vertical tangents, when is undefined due to a zero denominator.
Slope of an implicit curve: The instantaneous rate at which y changes with respect to x, obtained by implicit differentiation and evaluated at a specific point on the relation.
A normal sentence must appear here to maintain spacing between definition blocks and the remainder of the text. Interpreting this slope helps identify turning behaviors and transitions in how the curve progresses across its domain.
Connecting First Implicit Derivatives to Critical Points
For implicitly defined curves, a critical point occurs where or where the derivative does not exist, provided that the point satisfies the original relation. These locations are essential when assessing local extrema or structural transitions on the curve.
To study critical points using implicit derivatives:
Substitute candidate points into to verify whether the slope is zero or undefined.
Confirm that each point lies on the implicit relation before considering it a true critical point.
Use the sign behavior of around these points to interpret changes in direction.
Critical point (implicit curve): A point on an implicitly defined relation where or is undefined, indicating possible extrema or directional changes.
A normal sentence between definition blocks ensures clear separation. These points act as anchors that shape the global behavior of the curve.
Using the Second Implicit Derivative to Understand Concavity
Second implicit derivatives are essential for interpreting how the slope itself changes. Because implicit relations mix x, y, and , the second derivative often involves multiple layers of differentiation.
= The rate at which the first derivative changes with respect to x, indicating concavity
A single sentence appears here to maintain required spacing and to introduce how concavity and curvature reflect deeper features of the curve. Concavity describes whether the curve bends upward or downward at a point, based on the sign of the second derivative.

The diagrams compare concave up and concave down curves and illustrate how the slopes of tangent lines increase or decrease accordingly. These visual patterns connect directly to the sign of . Although shown for explicit functions, the concavity–slope relationship applies equally to implicitly defined curves. Source.
Concavity interpretation guidelines:
If \frac{d^2 y}{dx^2} > 0 , the curve is concave up, bending like a cup.
If \frac{d^2 y}{dx^2} < 0 , the curve is concave down, arching over its domain.
A change in sign of the second derivative suggests a potential inflection point, provided the curve is defined near that location.

This graph shows a cubic curve changing concavity at a clearly marked inflection point. The curvature transitions from concave down to concave up as the second derivative changes sign. Although based on the function , the behavior illustrated is representative of any curve exhibiting an inflection point. Source.
Integrating First and Second Implicit Derivatives for Full Behavioral Insight
The combined information from the first and second derivatives provides a coherent description of how the curve behaves:
Slope behavior from shows increasing or decreasing tendencies.
Concavity behavior from reveals how steepness changes.
Critical points and curvature transitions together help map local maxima, minima, and inflection points, even when the function is not explicitly solved.
This detailed interpretation ensures that implicit curves can be analyzed with the same clarity and rigor as explicitly defined functions, aligning precisely with the expectations of the AP Calculus AB curriculum.
FAQ
Implicit curves often require substituting both x and y when evaluating derivatives, making interpretation more dependent on specific coordinate pairs.
Additionally, the derivative expressions can be more complex because they frequently mix x, y, and dy/dx, so determining slope or concavity involves more careful substitution and simplification.
A horizontal or vertical tangent is only meaningful if the corresponding point lies on the implicit relation itself.
• Horizontal tangents arise when the numerator of dy/dx is zero while the denominator is non-zero.
• Vertical tangents arise when the denominator is zero while the numerator is non-zero.
Points where both numerator and denominator are zero require additional analysis to confirm the tangent behaviour.
Because implicit differentiation produces expressions involving both y and dy/dx, differentiating again leads to new derivative terms that reintroduce dy/dx.
These substitutions ensure the final expression is entirely in terms of x, y, and dy/dx, which is required for interpreting concavity without needing to solve for y explicitly.
Yes. Implicit curves can bend sharply or change concavity rapidly, especially near points where the relation has tight curvature or multiple branches.
This happens because the graph does not need to pass the vertical line test, allowing for shapes that explicit functions cannot produce.
The second derivative gives a strong indication of potential inflection points, but a sign change must still be confirmed across the point.
Because implicit curves can have breaks or undefined regions, it is also essential to verify that the curve exists on both sides of the candidate point before concluding that an inflection point occurs.
Practice Questions
A curve is defined implicitly by the relation 3xy + y² = 12.
(a) Find the slope dy/dx at the point (2, 3).
(1–3 marks)
Question 1
(a)
• Differentiates implicitly to obtain dy/dx = ( -3y ) / ( 3x + 2y ). (1 mark)
• Substitutes (2, 3) correctly to obtain dy/dx = -9 / 12. (1 mark)
• Simplifies to obtain -3/4. (1 mark)
A curve is defined implicitly by the equation x² + xy + y³ = 10.
(a) Find an expression for dy/dx.
(b) Hence determine the second derivative d²y/dx² in terms of x, y, and dy/dx.
(c) At the point (1, 2), determine whether the curve is concave up or concave down.
(4–6 marks)
Question 2
(a)
• Differentiates implicitly: 2x + (x dy/dx + y) + 3y² dy/dx = 0. (1 mark)
• Rearranges to obtain dy/dx = ( -2x - y ) / ( x + 3y² ). (1 mark)
(b)
• Differentiates dy/dx correctly using quotient rule or equivalent. (1 mark)
• Substitutes dy/dx where necessary to maintain expression in terms of x, y, and dy/dx only. (1 mark)
(c)
• Substitutes x = 1 and y = 2 into dy/dx and into the expression for the second derivative. (1 mark)
• States concave up if d²y/dx² > 0 or concave down if d²y/dx² < 0. (1 mark)
